Indult Tihota vs BDK Parfums Stellar Silk is the clearest choice in niche vanilla: sweet against powdery. Tihota ($220, 50 ml) is Francis Kurkdjian's 2006 Tahitian vanilla, almost nothing but vanilla and musk. Stellar Silk ($440, 100 ml) is Jordi Fernández's 2026 absolu, where orris and sandalwood pull the vanilla away from dessert entirely.
The short answer
Buy Tihota if you want vanilla and very little else — a warm, sweet, skin-close vanilla that has been the reference point for twenty years. Buy Stellar Silk if you like vanilla but not sweetness, and want something with cosmetic powder and dry wood in it that you could wear to an office.
How they compare
| Indult Tihota | BDK Parfums Stellar Silk | |
|---|---|---|
| Launched | 2006 | 2026 |
| Perfumer | Francis Kurkdjian | Jordi Fernández |
| Concentration | Eau de parfum | Absolu de parfum |
| Notes | Tahitian vanilla, sugar cane, white musk, tonka bean, amber, almond milk | Cinnamon, ginger; Bourbon vanilla, butter, orris, tonka bean, Siam benzoin; white sandalwood |
| Top accords | Vanilla 100, sweet 34, powdery 32 | Vanilla 100, powdery 82, woody 76, warm spicy 66, iris 51 |
| Fragrantica rating | 4.34 / 5 from 2,332 votes | 4.20 / 5 from 443 votes |
| Size / price | 50 ml, $220 | 100 ml, $440 |
| Price per ml | $4.40 | $4.40 |
What Tihota actually smells like
Tihota is close to a vanilla soliflore. The material list is short — Tahitian vanilla, sugar cane, white musk, tonka bean, amber and almond milk — and it behaves exactly as that reads. There is no fruit, no booze, no smoke. Fragrantica's community ranks vanilla at full weight and then drops sharply: sweet at 34 and powdery at 32, with everything else in single figures. That gap is the whole character. Nothing competes with the vanilla.
What keeps it from being flat is the almond milk and the musk, which give it a lactonic, skin-like softness rather than a bakery sweetness. It sits close and it lasts, and at 4.34 out of 5 from 2,332 votes it is one of the best-liked vanillas in niche perfumery. Francis Kurkdjian composed it in 2006, well before the house that carries his name became the reference it is now.
One honest note: Fragrantica files Tihota as a women's fragrance, though the house and most wearers treat it as unisex, and nothing in the composition is gendered.
What Stellar Silk actually smells like
Stellar Silk takes the opposite route. It opens on Laotian cinnamon and ginger — dry spice, no fruit and no caramel — and the heart is where the argument happens: Bourbon vanilla sits with orris butter, tonka bean and Siam benzoin. Orris is the decisive material. It is the rhizome of the iris, aged for years before processing, and it smells cool, powdery and faintly rooty. Against vanilla it does something unusual: it pulls the whole thing out of the bakery and into a cosmetic register, closer to face powder than to pudding.
The base is Australian white sandalwood, used generously, which is why the drydown reads like fabric rather than food. The community accord ranking backs that up: vanilla first, but powdery at 82 and woody at 76 close behind, with iris clearly present at 51. Compare that with Tihota's powdery 32 and the difference is measurable, not just a matter of description.
The sweetness gap, in numbers
If you only read one line of data, read this one. Tihota's community accords run vanilla 100, sweet 34, powdery 32. Stellar Silk's run vanilla 100, powdery 82, woody 76, warm spicy 66. Both are unmistakably vanillas; one is a sweet one with a hint of powder, the other is a powdery woody one that happens to be built on vanilla.
That is why people who love one often bounce off the other. If you want the comfort-blanket vanilla, Stellar Silk will read as dry and almost austere. If sweetness in perfume tires you quickly, Tihota will read as one-dimensional.
Which one should you buy?
Buy Tihota if: vanilla is the point, you want it warm and close to the skin, and you would rather have one material done properly than a composition. It is also the smaller commitment at $220 for 50 ml.
Buy Stellar Silk if: you like iris and find most iris fragrances too cold, or you like vanilla and find most vanillas too edible. It is the more versatile of the two across settings, and the absolu concentration means long wear from a light application.
On price: they come out identical per millilitre, at $4.40 each. The difference is the commitment — $220 for 50 ml of Tihota against $440 for 100 ml of Stellar Silk. If you are not certain, the smaller bottle is the lower-risk way in.
For the wider picture, our vanilla note page and the amber vanilla family show what else sits between these two, and orris is the page to browse if the Stellar Silk description is what caught you. Every house we stock is on the brands page.
Redolia is a niche perfume store online that ships across the US, and both are available to smell at our Somerville, NJ boutique. Standard shipping is free on US orders of $79 or more; under $79 you pay the carrier rate you choose at checkout.
Updated November 2026
Tihota vs Stellar Silk: frequently asked questions
Is Stellar Silk sweeter than Tihota?
No, the other way round. Fragrantica's community accords put Tihota at sweet 34 against powdery 32, while Stellar Silk runs powdery 82 and woody 76 behind its vanilla. Tihota is the sweet one; Stellar Silk is the powdery, woody one.
Which is the better beginner vanilla?
Tihota, if what you want is vanilla. It is short, legible and warm, and at $220 for 50 ml it is the smaller commitment. Stellar Silk is the better choice for someone who already knows they dislike sweetness.
Who created Indult Tihota?
Francis Kurkdjian composed Tihota for Indult; it launched in 2006. Fragrantica rates it 4.34 out of 5 from 2,332 votes.
Who created BDK Stellar Silk?
Jordi Fernández composed Stellar Silk for BDK Parfums, launched in 2026 as part of the house's Collection Studio tier. Fragrantica rates it 4.20 out of 5 from 443 votes.
Is Tihota unisex?
The house and most wearers treat it as unisex and nothing in the composition is gendered, though Fragrantica files it as a women's fragrance. Stellar Silk is listed for women and men.
What is orris, and why does it matter here?
Orris is the rhizome of the iris, aged for years before processing. It smells cool, powdery and faintly rooty. In Stellar Silk it is what pulls the vanilla away from a dessert reading and into a cosmetic, face-powder register. Tihota contains no orris.
Which is better value, Tihota or Stellar Silk?
They are identical per millilitre at $4.40. Tihota is $220 for 50 ml and Stellar Silk is $440 for 100 ml, so the real difference is how much you want to commit up front.
Where can I buy Tihota and Stellar Silk in the US?
Redolia is a niche perfume store online that ships across the US and carries both. You can also smell them side by side at our Somerville, NJ boutique.





